Game Show sketches are a common type of sketch appearing on All That. Typically the rules are rather arbitrary or difficult to logically follow, and will leave at least one player bewildered, while another player and the host have no issue.
| || Masked Video Game Dancer: Celebrity Edition|
Episode 1101: The Jonas Brothers
|Nick Cannon (Lex Lumpkin) hosts this game show where the judges, Beyonce (Gabrielle Nevaeh Green), Ariana Grande (Nathan Janak), & Dwane "The Rock" Johnson (Chinguun Sergelen), guess what celebrities are behind the mask dancing.|
Episode 1103: Kane Brown
|Dell Devine hosts "Simplicity," the world's easiest Game Show|
| Boo’d Up|
Episode 1105: The Cast of Henry Danger/Ella Mai
|Ella Mai tries to find a ghost to haunt her house.|
Episode 1107: Ciara
|"Simplicity” returns, with host Dell Divine still giving returning loser Larry a hard time.|
| || Stay Off Your Phone|
Episode 1115: AJ Mitchell
|A game show where contestants, Amber, Sarah, and Jordan have to stay off of their phones. Amber forfeits immediately, while Sarah and Jordan tough it out to round two, where Sarah can't resist the temptation to not take a slefie with Barack Obama near a double rainbow. Jordan however also loses when he gets on his phone to tell people he won.|
Episode 1120: Bad Bunny
|27 time loser, Larry VanHalen returns yet again, but manages to win when he sticks his hand in the lucky bear trap. Unfortunately for him, the rules state that every 28 games the winner, not the loser, has to return.|
| Stay Off Your Phone|
Episode 1122: Why Don't We
|Chelsea, her Mom and James compete to see who can stay off their phones, despite trendng topics, listening to a boring person tell a story, a cat dressed like Ariana Grande, and Ariana Grande dressed like a cat.|
| Stay Off Your Phone|
Episode 1131: HRVY
|Will, Ian and Lorraine compete to see who can stay off their phones, despite a series of new apps, waiting for food at Kantsuya, and getting a surprise appearance from the cast of Stranger Things.|
- Episode 0109: Soul 4 Real: What's in the Box?: In a game show, contestants must try to figure out what item is concealed a box. The host (Josh Server) keeps his cool until one insane contestant (Lori Beth Denberg) can't determine what round, orange-colored fruit used to make juice is concealed inside. As she repeatedly makes inane guesses, the host gradually goes crazy trying to get her to get the right answer.
- Episode 0219: Shai: Let's Get Messy: A game show where kids get their parents extremely messy.
- Episode 0317: Az Yet: Family vs. Family (The Kopelows vs. the Maroons): The Maroons go against the Kopelows in this game show. The Kopelows are named after the stage manager Kevin Kopelow.
- Episode 0320: MC Lyte: You Can't Win: The game show where no one can win, hosted by Jerry Fytootal (Josh). The panelists are Megan (Amanda Bynes); Shelley (Alisa Reyes); and Antoine (Kenan Thompson). Near the end of the sketch, Antoine gets "an entire ten seconds" to consume a big bowl of vanilla pudding; with 1½ seconds left, though, he dumps it on top of Jerry's head and bolts, laughing and smiling.
- Episode 0402: Busta Rhymes: What Do You Do?: The Game show where panelists must guess what the contestant's weird hobby is. The host Is Winter Wonders. The panelists are Principal Wiliam Baines Pimpell, Miss Fingerly, Coach Kreeton, and Kevin (who isn't wearing any pants) where they have to guess the hobbies of two different contestants (Amanda and Leon Frierson).
- Episode 0413: Boyz II Men: What Do You Do?: The panelists who attempt to guess the talent of Megan Marples are Connie Muldoon, Detective Dan, Lump Maroon, and Lester Oaks, Construction Worker.
- Episode 0506: Faith Evans: You Can't Win: Jerry Fytootal has three new challengers: Arnie Fishback (Mark), Lester Oaks, Construction Worker, and Helga Schlumpkenfist (Danny). Lester Oaks quits the game after realizing Jerry isn't letting them win. Helga loses because she accidentally exceeds the number of meatballs she must eat; she eats 403 meatballs as opposed to the 400 she has to. She then proceeds to viciously assault Jerry, and declare herself the winner.
- Episode 0507: Mýa: Best Friends Forever Show: A show where you win prizes if you let the host (Kenan) do something horrible to your best friend which involved either being tickled, having some of your teeth ripped out, having honey put on your face where a polar bear licks it, and even be shot into space.
- Episode 0513: Divine: The Date Game: A girl (Christy) must choose whether she should go out with Antoine, Lump Maroon, or Francis the Caveman.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.